Заудрагон++;

if (Zaudragon == 15) { printf("%s\n", "Заудрагон++;"); }

23.1.08

Swastika Pillows

Today in US History, we talked about the Confederacy as a symbol, namely through its flag and various memorabilia that surrounds it.

While almost everyone agreed that a Confederate flag is acceptable but a Swastika was not, I thought a Swastika was totally OK. My teacher, clearly very… intrigued by my stance, pointed how bad the Germans were in the 40s.

However, this exemplifies a great double standard in how the US views itself and how they view the Nazis.
Examples of similarities and comparisons between the US and the Third Reich:
  1. The Nazis rounded up all the Jews, and killed them mercilessly.
    Compare: The US rounded up all the Japanese during WWII and withheld general freedoms, they enslaved an entire race of a continent, changing its culture forever, and killed probably more people in combined wars ever (because of its huge role in industrial manufacturing).
    Impact Calculus: The US obviously did more damage than the Third Reich, seeing as they enslaved a whole continent and provided for 1000-fold amount of killing through manufacturing guns, munitions, and even foodstuffs during the isolationist era. A bunch of European wars were sourced by American food
  2. The Nazis destroyed Democracy, and instead placed a dictator who step-by-step stripped away liberties
    Compare: The US is launching an even scarier attack on civil liberties. While the Nazi attack was obvious, the Americans are less careful, because they have the Constitution that allows for slow undermining. Government Surveillance, Bureaucracy, Capitalism, etc. all fall in this category.
    Impact Calculus: The US probably is doing more damage than the Third Reich could ever do, but not at an accelerated pace. It's even worse because while the Nazi attack was obvious, the American attack on liberties is subtle and ever-occurring.
Those are two points, and are usually the larger ones.
The Germans, remember, also:
  1. Boomed their economy in a few short years.
  2. Used nationalism to its greatest extent, as used by the US in all its (rather frequent, if I might add) wars.
  3. Exemplified and proved how Nietzschean Will-to-Power works in the real world, that it requires some underdog that is pushed down and taken advantage of and used as teaching tools to teach the people not to fear and to be powerful to prevent this themselves.
The only argument in favour of the US I see is that the Nazis were like Distilled Alcohol, with much more "evil" or "bad" content per year. US aggregate evil-ness, on the other hand, so grossly outweighs Nazi evil that there is no comparison.

And the Nazis had a neat flag and goose-step, not to mention armbands. I wish they could be acceptable to wear/do again, because they're rather funny and cool.

1 Comments:

At 02/03/08 12:26, Anonymous Anonymous said…

Yurij says-

While I take issue with your arguments specifically (it would be foolish to say that, being Japanese, you are completely objective in the first point, and we're not fans of similar political models [re CIvil Liberties], and to compare American arms sell-ation to deliberate and calculated extermination is a bit of a stretch) I agree that there is a gross double standard regarding the use of the swastika. But not with the Confederate flag. It's on this very blog.

NOBODY, and when I say nobody, I mean nobody, cares if you wear a shirt or button or sticker with a hammer and sickle, or a picture of Mao, or anything like that. Communism is a big joke. Fascism? OMG, BUSH IS TEH FASCIST!!!1@¡12! If you even SAY Hitler, you've just made whatever you were talking about significantly more edgy and uncomfortable. Stalin? Mao? Yeah, whatever.

So how many people did Hitler kill again? 9 million (IT'S NOT SIX MILLION, whatever your overly anti-anti-Semetic history books/teachers may tell you, and it;s not like we talk about the other 3 mil anyway [yes, as a Ukranian, I'm biased.]). Stalin killed 20. Mao killed 30

and NO. BODY. CARES.


So I agree with your opinion that swastikas are totally OK and if one has a problem with swastikas and not communist stuff, we need to have a talk. You're either Jewish (which I guess is understandable) or severly deluded and brainwashed. And it came from India, OK? It's a RELIGIOUS SYMBOL. Just like the "Nazi Salute" came from ROME (and the US used to use it too.)

[/rant]

sorry about that. This issue really gets me angry (not your post. I agree. just, people in general)

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home